Fans Vote Huda as Top Beauty, With Amaya, Chelley, and Olandria Close Behind

July 24, 2025 – Los Angeles, CA - In a stunning turn of events, Huda Mustafa has been voted the most beautiful female contestant of Love Island USA Season 7, according to an exclusive poll conducted by our entertainment desk. The 24-year-old fitness instructor and influencer from Raleigh, North Carolina, captured the hearts of fans with her striking looks, bold personality, and unapologetic presence in the villa. The poll, which saw thousands of votes from viewers across the country, highlights Huda’s magnetic appeal, despite her polarizing journey on the Peacock reality dating show.

Huda’s rise to the top spot comes as no surprise to her growing fanbase, which has propelled her to 1.8 million Instagram followers and 2.4 million on TikTok, making her the most followed Islander of the season. Known for her dramatic flair and emotional authenticity, Huda’s beauty—both inside and out—resonated with voters who admired her confidence and vulnerability. “Huda’s not just gorgeous; she’s real. She wears her heart on her sleeve, and that’s what makes her stand out,” one fan commented on social media.

Following closely behind Huda, the poll ranked Amaya Espinal as the second most beautiful Islander. The charismatic fan favorite, often affectionately called “Amaya Papaya,” won over viewers with her theatrical charm and wholesome heart. Her radiant smile and vibrant energy made her a standout, with fans rallying behind her to reach 1 million Instagram followers during the season. Amaya’s journey culminated in her winning the season alongside partner Bryan Arenales, solidifying her status as a beloved figure.

Chelley Bissainthe, the astrology-loving fashion model from Orlando, Florida, secured the third spot. Chelley’s vibrant personality and stunning looks, coupled with her intuitive approach to relationships, made her a favorite among voters. Fans praised her for her bold style and strong presence in the villa, with one voter noting, “Chelley’s confidence and beauty are unmatched—she’s a star.”

Rounding out the top four is Olandria Carthen, the beauty-with-brains graduate of Tuskegee University. Known for her jet-setting lifestyle and grounded demeanor, Olandria’s natural elegance and “big sister” energy earned her high praise. Her ability to stay true to herself while navigating the villa’s drama resonated with fans, who dubbed her a “girl’s girl” and a “10/10, no notes.”

The poll also highlighted other notable Islanders, including Belle-A Walker, whose charm and work at her family’s coffee shop added a relatable touch to her glamorous persona, and Cierra Ortega, whose early departure didn’t dim her shine as a fan favorite. While Huda’s top ranking sparked some debate online, with some fans surprised by her edge over Amaya and Olandria, the results reflect the diverse appeal of this season’s cast.

Season 7 of Love Island USA has been a rollercoaster, marked by record-breaking viewership and heated online discussions. The show, which aired six days a week on Peacock, garnered over 1.2 billion minutes viewed in its first two weeks alone. Huda’s polarizing presence, from her intense connection with Jeremiah Brown to her emotional recoupling with Chris Seeley, kept viewers glued to their screens. Despite facing criticism for her dramatic moments, her beauty and bold gameplay have clearly left a lasting impression.

As the season wraps, the poll results celebrate the diverse beauty and personalities of the Love Island USA women, with Huda Mustafa leading the pack as the fans’ choice for the most beautiful Islander of Season 7.